Alan E. Steinweis, Daniel E. Rogers, eds.
The Impact of Nazism: New Perspectives on the Third Reich and Its Legacy.
Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2003. xvii + 260 pp.
$49.95 (cloth), ISBN 978-0-8032-4299-9.
Reviewed by Hilary Earl (Department of History, Nipissing University)
Published on H-German (January, 2004)
Published on H-German (January, 2004)
If an essay collection is difficult to review, a
Festschrift is usually impossible. The latter frequently lacks cohesion
because its organizing principle is more often than not a person and
not an historical question or issue. Honoring an eminent scholar--while
admirable--does not generally lend itself to an integrated historical
analysis, especially when the contributors have only the honoree in
common. The Impact of Nazism: New Perspectives on the Third Reich and its Legacy,
a collection of essays edited by Alan Steinweis and Daniel Rogers in
honor of the pre-eminent German scholar Gerhard Weinberg, is an
exception. The contributors of this volume, all scholars in their own
right, are also former students of Weinberg and thus their research and
his, have much in common.
As the title suggests, the book is a collection of
thirteen essays devoted to an examination of the impact of Nazism on
various individuals, national groups, social institutions, and political
movements. While the essays are not clearly delineated by chapters
(this is not unexpected as one essay does not a chapter make), themes
can be easily identified. Not surprisingly, many of the essays deal
specifically with the effects of Nazi racial and population policy on
various groups in and outside of Germany. For instance, Johnpeter Horst
Grill, in "The American South and Nazi Racism," offers an examination of
the ways in which Nazi racial policy influenced the debate about social
equality in the southern United States, especially the discourse about
the place of African Americans in American society. His study finds
that for those people who already harbored racist attitudes, Nazi racial
policy was embraced as an example to emulate, whereas for liberals
whose tendency it was to promote social equality and justice, the
opposite was true. Alan Steinweis' "Antisemitic Scholarship in the
Third Reich and the Case of Peter-Heinz Seraphim" takes a longer view
than Grill in his study of the lingering effects of Nazi antisemitism on
the German academy. In his examination of the ways in which German
scholars contributed to the persecution of European Jewry, Steinweis
concludes that the antisemitic "scholarship" of contemporaries such as
Seraphim--a leading Nazi Jewish scholar--had a profoundly negative
impact on the development of Nazi racial policy during the Third Reich
as well as a lasting effect in contemporary Germany which manifested in
the absence of the legitimate study of Jewish life and culture in
universities until relatively recently.
Two essays on the impact of population and
resettlement policy, "A Reassessment of Volksdeutsche and Jews in the
Volhynia-Galicia-Narew Resettlement" by Valdis Lumans and "The
Volksdeutsche of Eastern Europe and the Collapse of the Nazi Empire,
1944-1945" by Doris Bergen, are particularly illuminating. Lumans
offers a reassessment of his earlier analysis (1993) of the role of
resettlement policy on the origins of the "Final Solution" in light of
recent scholarship on the subject. In particular, Lumans challenges
Goetz Aly's position about the functionalist origins of the Holocaust,
acknowledging the important but nonetheless limited role local officials
played in the execution of Nazi racial policy in the region, while
emphasizing the centrality of Berlin in the decision-making process.
Bergen, on the other hand, offers a case study of the immediate and
long-term effects of population policy on the ethnic Germans of eastern
Europe which, in her view, was disastrous. She notes that the ethnic
Germans of this area found their fate intimately linked to, and affected
by, the German war effort and the regime's genocidal policy in more
than material ways. Not only did Nazi resettlement policy cause a
permanent shift of population transfers and ethnic boundaries, it also
caused the erasure of ethnic coexistence. During the earlier years of
the war, the Nazis emphasized racial hostility and competition, but at
war's end, when it was fairly clear that the Germans would lose, ethnic
Germans who had benefited from the earlier policy simply refused to
abandon these ideas and found themselves, as a result, struggling to
find a satisfactory place within their new communities.
A second, but equally important focus of the book
includes those essays devoted to issues of the internal organization of
the Third Reich, especially the role of the military and paramilitary
organizations in the functioning of the state and the execution of the
"Final Solution." In one essay of particular interest to this reviewer,
Edward Westermann's "Shaping the Police Soldier as an Instrument for
Annihilation," Westermann offers a new interpretation of the reasons for
the behavior of the police units on the eastern front, in the genocidal
campaign that began with Operation Barbarossa in June 1941 and
culminated in the European-wide murder of the Jews. Largely in response
to the debate generated by Goldhagen's so-called ordinary Germans and
Browning's ordinary men, but also building on his earlier work on Police
Battalion 310,[1] Westermann posits an alternative explanation for why
German policeman became exceptional killers. The answer is, in part,
organizational. The forced militarization of the German police, coupled
with their merger into the SS and subsequent indoctrination, meant that
when the time came to carry out the racial war in the east in 1941, the
Nazis found themselves with police battalions that were already well
prepared "instruments of annihilation." Westermann's conclusions are
reinforced in a subsequent article by David Yelton, "The SS, NSDAP, and
the Question of Volkssturm Expansion."
A third theme of the collection, the nature and
functioning of power in the Third Reich, is highlighted in a comparative
essay by Alan Wilt on the High Command structures of Germany, Britain
and the United States. Here, Wilt emphasizes Hitler's influence on the
command structure of the German military and the negative impact this
had on military strategy and ultimately the outcome of the war. Yelton's
essay on the creation and expansion of the Volkssturm, on the
other hand, clearly illustrates the polycratic nature of the regime and
the fierce competition that resulted from it, in this instance between
the NSDAP (Bormann) and the SS (Himmler). The collection fittingly ends
with a lengthy discussion of the legacy of Nazism in the legal, economic
and political arenas in the context of war's end and the emergence of
the fledgling Federal Republic. Daniel Rogers's concluding essay about
the confrontation by the postwar German Chancellors with the Nazi past
(particularly the Holocaust) suggests that the challenges posed by such
a negative history have not yet disappeared. Because the troubling
legacy of Nazism has not dissipated over time, what is certain,
according to Rogers, is that at the highest levels of government the
debate about the place of the Third Reich and its genocidal policy in
German history will remain ambiguous.
Admittedly, this collection contains a wide variety
of essays on divergent aspects of the history of the Third Reich. As a
result, it is perhaps not as focused as a collection that is devoted to a
single theme might otherwise be. Nonetheless, The Impact of Nazism
is an important book for a number of reasons, not the least of which is
the high level of scholarship by the authors of this collection and the
substantial contribution to the field of modern German history that
each author makes individually and the book makes collectively. There
is no doubt that the essays highlighted here add new insight into
persistent and vexing questions about the place of the Third Reich in
German history, the nature and functioning of the Nazi state, and the
development and impact of population, racial, and foreign policy.
Whether you are interested in the character of European fascism and the
impact that Nazism had on fascist movements outside of Germany or the
ways in which Germans confronted their recent past, there is an essay
here for virtually everyone. On a more personal level, the book might
be more appropriately titled, "Gerhard Weinberg's Legacy" which, in the
form of a coterie of young, enthusiastic, and committed scholars, is
indeed an impressive and important one. I recommend this book to anyone
interested in learning more about how Nazism impacted a wide-range of
people in different countries and in different aspects of their lives. I
also recommend it to those who teach advanced level courses on the
history of the Third Reich because many of the essays here could be
easily incorporated into various themes of such a course. Finally, the
collection should be read by experts whose research intersects with the
contributors of this book because, as I have suggested, the essays in
this collection indeed add new perspectives to old interpretive
questions of the functioning and legacy of the Third Reich.
Note
[1]. Edward Westermann, "'Ordinary men' or 'ideological soldiers'? Police Battalian 310 in Russia, 1942," in German Studies Review 21 (February 1998), pp. 41-68.
Copyright (c) 2004 by H-Net, all rights
reserved. H-Net permits the redistribution and reprinting of this work
for nonprofit, educational purposes, with full and accurate attribution
to the author, web location, date of publication, originating list, and
H-Net: Humanities & Social Sciences Online. For other uses contact
the Reviews editorial staff: hbooks@mail.h-net.msu.edu.
No comments:
Post a Comment